There are two ways to be selected into the Hall of Fame:
1 - Earn All-State honors in an IHSA Sanctioned Sport.
2 - Earn at least 6 Varsity Letters and
2a - be named All-Conference in two different sports
| George Verber | 1960 | Basketball, Baseball | ||
| Lee Wolf | 1961 | Track | ||
| William Downing | 1963 | Gymnsatics | ||
| Al Walters | 1963 | Football, Basketball | ||
| Dan Humay | 1963 | Baseball | ||
| Chip Allen | 1963 | Baseball | ||
| David Aegerter | 1964 | Football | ||
| John Gabbert | 1964 | Baseball | ||
| Joseph Wehlacz | 1964 | Basketball | ||
| Jim Smith | 1965 | Basketball | ||
| Stoney Jackson | 1965 | Football, Basketball, Baseball | ||
| John Greco | 1965 | Cross Country | ||
| Eddie Lusk | 1966 | Cross Country, Track | ||
| Gustavo Herrero | 1966 | Tennis | ||
| Craig Rowells | 1967 | Football | ||
| Larry Scully | 1967 | Gymnastics | ||
| Bob Banger | 1968 | Football | ||
| Bruce Kaechele | 1968 | Football, Basketball | ||
| Lee LeBadie | 1968 | Cross Country, Track | ||
| Bob Glitz | 1970 | Cross Country | ||
| Jerry Krainik | 1971 | Track | ||
| Bruce Beam | 1971 | Wrestling | ||
| Tom Kummer | 1971 | Basketball | ||
| Jack St John | 1972 | Cross Country | ||
| Kim Tuttle | 1973 | Volleyball, Badminton, Softball | ||
| Bill Klippert | 1974 | Track | ||
| Steve Zuccarini | 1975 | Football, Basketball, Baseball | ||
| Karen Gafrick | 1975 | Swimming, Basketball, Softball | ||
| Joe Paul | 1975 | Track | ||
| John Bachmeier | 1976 | Soccer | ||
| Felix Garos | 1976 | Soccer | ||
| Tony Krainik | 1977 | Track | ||
| Bob Zuccarini | 1977 | Football, Basketball, Baseball | ||
| Brian Tolan | 1977 | Cross Country, Track | ||
| Tim Richardson | 1978 | Football, Basketball, Baseball | ||
| Nancy Webber | 1978 | Badminton | ||
| Dave Cavazos | 1978 | Wrestling | ||
| Jim Lindeman | 1979 | Baseball | ||
| Maureen Moeller | 1979 | Volleyball | ||
| Meg Gravesmill | 1980 | Archery, Fencing, Badminton | ||
| Jymette Bonnivier | 1980 | Track | ||
| Mark Voss | 1980 | Football | ||
| Rick Schulte | 1981 | Football | ||
| Lory Tonske | 1981 | Cross Country, Track | ||
| Christy Nelson | 1982 | Volleyball, Basketball, Track | ||
| John Dobbs | 1982 | Track | ||
| Mary McMahon | 1982 | Basketball | ||
| Chris Walsh | 1982 | Cross Country, Track | ||
| Jim Carroll | 1982 | Basketball, Baseball, Gymnastics | ||
| Nancy Sperling | 1983 | Fencing | ||
| Bill Friday | 1983 | Track | ||
| Denise Dzik | 1983 | Badminton | ||
| Aurora Zurlo | 1983 | Badminton | ||
| Mary Just | 1983 | Basketball | ||
| Tony Paul | 1983 | Track | ||
| Jesse Bozman | 1983 | Track | ||
| Mike Dorion | 1983 | Wrestling | ||
| Don Paulsen | 1983 | Gymnastics | ||
| Bridget Boyajian | 1983 | Cross Country | ||
| Cheryl Stenzel | 1984 | Basektball, Track | ||
| Deanne Dzik | 1984 | Volleyball, Track | ||
| Mike McCabe | 1984 | Gymnastics | ||
| Dan Wrona | 1984 | Soccer | ||
| Linda Sherkey | 1985 | Basketball, Track | ||
| Patricia Kiraly | 1985 | Cross Country | ||
| Dana DeRosa | 1985 | Basketball | ||
| Tracy Granzyk | 1985 | Basketball, Softball | ||
| Diane DeSantis | 1985 | Basketball | ||
| Troy Anderson | 1985 | Track | ||
| James Hoferitza | 1985 | Football, Baseball | ||
| Joe Mueller | 1985 | Soccer | ||
| John Narve | 1985 | Wrestling | ||
| Gay Crain | 1986 | Basketball, Softball | ||
| Debbie Sperling | 1986 | Fencing | ||
| Susan Pawelko | 1986 | Cross Country, Track | ||
| Amy Omland | 1986 | Volleyball, Basketball | ||
| Liesel Krebs | 1986 | Badminton | ||
| Carrie Gorene | 1986 | Badminton | ||
| Jeff Gallagher | 1986 | Cross Country | ||
| Jodi Townsend | 1986 | Cross Country, Track | ||
| Nick Barone | 1987 | Tennis | ||
| Andy Miller | 1988 | Gymnastics | ||
| Sharla Barone | 1988 | Tennis | ||
| Stephanie Pinske | 1988 | Badminton | ||
| Deanna Serino | 1988 | Badminton | ||
| Tom Stanko | 1988 | Football, Basektball, Baseball | ||
| Eugene Sullivan | 1988 | Football, Wrestling | ||
| Scott Frankenthor | 1988 | Football, Basketball, Baseball | ||
| Heather Ertel | 1988 | Swimming, Basektball, Track | ||
| Nancy Kennelly | 1988 | Basketball | ||
| Tasia Georganas | 1989 | Basketball | ||
| Marien Garcia | 1989 | Cross Country, Track | ||
| Mary Spielman | 1989 | Basketball | ||
| Jason Markworth | 1990 | Soccer, Basketball, Volleyball | ||
| Cristy Nelson | 1990 | Basketball | ||
| Dale Eeles | 1990 | Football, Basketball, Baseball | ||
| Heather Podgorski | 1990 | Volleyball, Basketball, Softball | ||
| Moira Kennelly | 1990 | Basketball | ||
| Jenny Argianas | 1991 | Basketball | ||
| Chuck Van Hyning | 1991 | Wrestling | ||
| Jessica Orstead | 1992 | Basketball, Softball | ||
| Jacki Luckritz | 1992 | Volleyball, Track | ||
| Kerry Wegrzyn | 1992 | Volleyball, Basketball, Track | ||
| Mike Kane | 1992 | Football, Basketball, Baseball | ||
| Kathy Witte | 1993 | Basketball | ||
| Karen Slatkay | 1993 | Basketball | ||
| Craig Colson | 1993 | Swimming, Track | ||
| Jamie Pekoe | 1993 | Basketball | ||
| Brian Johnson | 1993 | Basketball | ||
| Scott Haack | 1993 | Soccer, Baseball | ||
| Jenny Grandy | 1993 | Volleyball, Softball | ||
| Katie Fregetto | 1993 | Basketball, Track | ||
| Dave Weber | 1993 | Golf, Tennis | ||
| Teri Bartholomew | 1993 | Basketball, Soccer | ||
| Garrett Larkin | 1993 | Football, Basketball | ||
| Josh Didier | 1994 | Football, Wrestling | ||
| Keith Burger | 1994 | Football, Wrestling | ||
| Dawn Smith | 1994 | Basketball, Soccer | ||
| Carmella Schaecher | 1994 | Cross Country, Track | ||
| Leslie Fredricks | 1994 | Cross Country, Track | ||
| John Vana | 1994 | Soccer, Basketball, Baseball | ||
| Rodney Berganos | 1995 | Tennis | ||
| Levy Cordero | 1995 | Tennis | ||
| Noe Dorantes | 1995 | Cross Country, Track | ||
| Mary Ellen Heidlauf | 1995 | Basketball, Softball | ||
| Tony Turner | 1996 | Football, Track | ||
| Eric Kriegermeier | 1996 | Football, Wrestling | ||
| Julie Fregetto | 1996 | Volleyball, Basketball, Track | ||
| Heather Pock | 1996 | Cross Country, Fencing, Track | ||
| Susan Soltysik | 1996 | Fencing, Track | ||
| Hector Castellanos | 1996 | Football, Wrestling, Track | ||
| Salena Miller | 1996 | Basketball | ||
| Agatha Mankiewicz | 1997 | Volleyball, Basketball, Track | ||
| Michelle Murillo | 1997 | Cross Country, Basketball | ||
| Steve Gonzalez | 1997 | Soccer | ||
| Jennifer Markanich | 1997 | Cross Country, Track | ||
| Chritopher Winter | 1997 | Football, Wrestling | ||
| Lance Weber | 1997 | Wrestling | ||
| Bradley Alesi | 1998 | Basketball, Baseball | ||
| Kevin Frey | 1998 | Basketball | ||
| Nicholas Woods | 1998 | Cross Country, Soccer | ||
| Brian Regan | 1998 | Soccer, Baseball | ||
| Lucas Johnson | 1998 | Basketball | ||
| Andrew Lightfoot | 1998 | Football | ||
| Dawn Vana | 1998 | Basketball | ||
| Anthony Ganas | 1998 | Wrestling | ||
| Heather Fitzgerald | 1998 | Volleyball, Basketball, Softball | ||
| Alex Muresan | 1998 | Tennis | ||
| Joseph Waski | 1999 | Wrestling | ||
| Thomas Mietus | 1999 | Football, Wrestling, Baseball | ||
| William Kopecky | 1999 | Wrestling, Baseball | ||
| Kevin Mueller | 1999 | Cross Country, Track | ||
| Joseph Weber | 1999 | Football, Wrestling | ||
| Christine Ries | 1999 | Badminton, Tennis | ||
| Amy Stolz | 1999 | Cross Country, Basketball, Track | ||
| Lynn Gorny | 1999 | Volleyball, Basketball | ||